Showing posts with label farmers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label farmers. Show all posts

Thursday, 17 December 2015

OUR FARMER FRIENDS

Banswara2.jpg

Our rural friends account for more than half of India's population but are a decisive factor in India's politics. As most of us city slickers do not understand the rural mind we find ourselves constantly confused by rural thinking that is so much a part of Indian politics.


The new government has focussed on rural India as a high priority area. The former deputy prime minister. Mr. Devi Lal, was quite correct in stating that India's urban elite do not understand rural India and its problems. Policy makers, bureaucrats, journalists intellectuals and others may have responded by trying to address themselves to this subject, but many of them have hazy or romantic ideas about the real aspirations of our rural masses.

Most city folk imagine the farmer to be some kind of noble savage. Under his grubby exterior… a heart of gold. He is popularly visualised as simple, humble, downtrodden, exploited, stupid, illiterate, though a hard-working fellow, who valiantly struggles against the awesome odds of erratic rains, infertile soils, exploitation by tyrannical landlords and heartless authorities.

Those who have interacted with the farmer, however, know that he can both be noble and savage. He may courageously offer his life for his landlord but also unhesitatingly steal half his crop. He will genuinely rejoice at his landlord's daughter's wedding or weep at his funeral but, will with equal sincerity steal whatever he feels the landlord does not actually need.

His attitude to the government is an extension of his attitude to his landlord. Historically, the government has always been a super landlord. Greek, Mughal, British or Hindu, rulers have all been equally distant foreign entities who ultimately owned their lands through many layers of officials who were regarded both as sources as well as objects of exploitation.

When banks first went into rural credit, the farmers found them easy game and recoveries were disastrous. It was only later when the bank agents established personal bonds and pleaded that their own jobs were at risk that the same poor farmers demonstrated their sense of honour and real financial strength. Farmers have taken full advantage of the recent populist rural policies and rural credit is in a shambles today.

The second characteristic of farmers is that they are the world's greatest complainers. Talk to any farmer, standing beside a bumper crop and you will have to listen to a long tale of sorrow. The problems with labour, insects, fungus, hail and rain or the lack of it and everything under the sun. Farming is a risky business especially in India's climate with its unpredictable floods and droughts. Therefore the farmer cannot be blamed for fearing the evil eye if he speaks too soon.

Self-confidence and pride beneath the humility is common in farmers. The same landless labourer who speaks of his sorrows, if encouraged, will show an almost arrogant disregard for his land lord, the local authorities or even for the opportunities of more income from more work. Humility diminishes inversely with rising caste hierarchy. They are humble whenever in a disadvantageous position, but arrogant when in a position of strength.

Despite their illiteracy, farmers are remarkably educated about the factors that affect their lives. It suits them to pretend to be ignorant fools till they have lulled visiting researchers, officials of other city slickers to reveal whether they have anything to offer or exploit. Then their crafty commonsense backed with a surprising fund of knowledge appears.

They have learned complex and difficult subjects like their caste system, religious mythology, politics and agriculture mostly through a non-formal system of learning. Yet they can quickly understand knowledge about tractors, trucks, pumps, videos and television sets. Their sense for finance is sharp and they understand the principles of diminishing marginal returns and opportunity costs better than their urban cousins. Though illiterate they are not uneducated. By contrast, it is in our cities that we find literates who are uneducated.

There are, however, limited horizons to a farmer's vision. India's cane lobby agitated for and gained a near doubling of cane prices this year. However, only 3% of cultivators grow cane so 97% farmers had to pay more for their gur and sugar. The generous prices for wheat and rice benefited those in the irrigated areas but hurt 70% farmers in the poorer hill and dryland areas. Farmers are not, therefore the best judges of all farmer’s interests in matters of legislation, planning or policy.

Rural poverty has become India's greatest national asset. Politicians and administrators encourage cultivators and promote their tales of woe. A chain of begging bowls stretches from the villages to the blocks, to the districts, to the state capitals, to the centre and then to the World Bank or other foreign benefactors. The sorrows are exaggerated at each stage, just as the benefits are siphoned off at each stage. No one actually wants to break this chain of bounty by abolishing poverty.

Ninety-two million cultivators and their households account for just over half the rural population but their surplus supports 55 million agricultural workers and almost as many millions in local crafts, trades and services. This wealth accounts for nearly half of India's national product, and the farmer's purchasing power is the main engine for industrial growth. The productivity of land is however low. Seventy eight per cent of India's cultivators are small with less than two hectares but they only control 28% of the land. In fact, their actual hold is much less. India may be a land of small farmers but it is not a land of small farms. Huge holdings in big farms survive despite land ceiling laws.

The powerful lobby of big farmers dominates politics at the centre and in the states and control the local administration in the districts. In the name of the poor farmers, they have succeeded in getting huge grants and subsidies which are paid for by the overtaxed urban sectors. Whoever said farmers were simple?


Murad Ali Baig


The Times of India 1991

Tuesday, 26 May 2015

COW SLAUGHTER IS MAINLY BULL


The image of `Gaomata’_  the white `Mother Cow’ with soulful eyes _  is beloved to many Hindus. The RSS, BJP and other opponents of cow slaughter would however be shocked to know that cows account for only 12% of all the bovines in India. They are not also the main producers of milk because female buffaloes account for 66% of India’s milch cattle and produce over 75% of the milk.
The 19th Livestock Census of India, 2012 also shows that India’s cows and other female bovines are in no great danger. The census shows that their numbers increased by 7.16% to 216 million since the previous census of 2007. It is the males of the species that are threatened as their numbers declined by 18.6% to 84 million in the same period. As male bovines today account for just 30% of the cattle population it clearly shows that it is the bulls and not cows that are being butchered.

Cattle are a huge economic asset to almost every rural family and the meat industry including bovines, sheep, goats, pigs and poultry put money into the pockets of nearly every rural household and they will suffer great economic loss if the India’s legislators ban or restrict the slaughter and sale of meat products. Beef, that costs a third of mutton, is also the poor man’s protein consumed by some 200 million Dalits and other tribal communities. There will be a strong political backlash if religious sentiments take precedence over economic realities. Anyone familiar with rural India knows that while there are many Muslims in the meat business the majority are Hindu.

The census shows that two-thirds of India’s cattle are female. This is because the value of male bovines that used to be valuable as draft animals or for meat is declining. Few people are aware that it is male animals (or birds) that are mostly used for meat as the females are more valuable as breeders and for milk or eggs. If males are not used for ploughing or transport they are only useful for their meat or hides. This gender imbalance is increasing rapidly and a recent report from the Central Institute of Agricultural Engineering Bhopal shows that the share of draught animals for farm power on Indian farms declined from 44% in 1971-72 to a shocking 4% in 2012-13 as tractors and electric and diesel pumps had replaced them. Bullock carts are now rare in many areas.

Not surprisingly millions of males have been culled. The census data also shows that male buffaloes declined 17.8% to 16 million while females increased 7.99% to 92 million. There are therefore nearly 6 female buffaloes to every male. It is only in the states where beef is being eaten that this gender imbalance is less pronounced. If hasty legislation cuts into meat consumption it will seriously injure rural incomes regardless of religion.

Paradoxically, the keepers of India’s cattle themselves perpetuate the worst crimes against cattle. In rural areas the females are valuable but the males are worthless and need food and fodder that costs over Rs. 100 a day. They are therefore killed for meat where it is allowed but in many states are callously driven away to be devoured by dogs or wild animals. Several million pregnant female bovines are brought into Indian cities for fresh milk. Half the calves they deliver are males that are an economic liability so they are callously killed as soon as the milking steadies. They are not humanely slaughtered by a stun gun or by beheading but are usually tied in the sun to slowly die of thirst and hunger. The state wise data shows that cattle slaughter is widespread and that economic compulsions outweigh religious sentiment in almost every urban and rural area.

India also has a serious problem with roughly 80 million old and unproductive cattle that are callously driven away until they die of hunger or illness. They do not harmlessly forage on barren land but, driven by hunger, raid productive farms and face the wrath of farmers who mercilessly beat and even kill them. They are a huge economic liability that takes food and economic opportunities away from millions of needy people. India’s 299 million cattle also need roughly 30 million hectares for their grazing as well as an equal amount of additional land for their fodder requirements. This is a huge chunk out of India’s 190 million hectares of cropped land. If states legislate against beef consumption if will add many more unproductive cattle demanding land that is not available.

There is no Hindu scripture opposed to the eating of meat or even beef. In fact Indra, the tawny bearded supreme Vedic god, was specifically offered the best sides of beef. The Vedas, Mahabharat, Ramayana, Shastras and other ancient texts all endorse eating meat and beef was even specified as the daan, or offering, reserved for Brahmins.   

The sentiment against beef is essentially political as it was associated with Muslims. Cow protection became a religious statement when the first movement to protect the cow was started by the Sikh Kuka (Namdhari) sect in 1870. In 1882, Dayanand Saraswati founded the Gorakshini Sabha that challenged beef eating provoking a series of communal riots in the 1880’s and 1890’s. These led to further communal clashes where many were killed in Azamgarh in 1893, Ayodhya in 1912 and Shahabad in 1917. Beef eating thus moved from being a matter of diet to a defining icon of Hindu versus Muslim identity. Hindu chauvinism could however make the ban on beef into an symbol of Brahmin tyranny over Dalits.

Though most Hindus may abhor eating beef, cattle breeders have long subordinated their religious sentiments to their economic compulsions. There is a strong religious sentiment but politicians as well as officials, and intellectuals need to consider this complex subject before rushing into legislation.